From 1d855e1633e53a28a682b80961b2189bd7ebf0c9 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: hzrd149 <github@hzrd149.com>
Date: Tue, 3 Dec 2024 11:52:29 -0600
Subject: [PATCH] move chunks to tags

---
 buds/10.md | 49 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++------------
 1 file changed, 37 insertions(+), 12 deletions(-)

diff --git a/buds/10.md b/buds/10.md
index ebd9bf0..15dbf0a 100644
--- a/buds/10.md
+++ b/buds/10.md
@@ -18,14 +18,20 @@ Clients MUST create a merkle tree using the chunk hashes as the leaf nodes
 
 Clients should publish a `2001` kind event after chunking the file in order to store the list of chunks
 
-The events `content` MUST be a new-line delimitated list of sha256 hashes
+The events MUST contain an ordered list of `chunk` tags with the sha256 hashes of the chunks
 
-```txt
-7e668b56a58c7891e0cf263ea3f093b75eebade23d663a45aa9920f347b3d671
-9b9c44a91396f19fd8700986eb0586dff2dcccf96c75bc2caefef302bcd78da1
-7a281548f1223664b855b10b08e59e84389ccabeb742517f6cd75eda2724a798
-fadeccee86b123088bbc452df10e8fbc99d4c2f22a70ef7a35605ec8e439c345
-5d62398419e6d136771541f3d2215e0ce31b1be45e99dbc64b43a4b734b447ca
+The `content` field MUST be a human readable description of the chunked file
+
+```json
+{
+  "tags": [
+    [ "chunk", "7e668b56a58c7891e0cf263ea3f093b75eebade23d663a45aa9920f347b3d671"],
+    [ "chunk", "9b9c44a91396f19fd8700986eb0586dff2dcccf96c75bc2caefef302bcd78da1"],
+    [ "chunk", "7a281548f1223664b855b10b08e59e84389ccabeb742517f6cd75eda2724a798"],
+    [ "chunk", "fadeccee86b123088bbc452df10e8fbc99d4c2f22a70ef7a35605ec8e439c345"],
+    [ "chunk", "5d62398419e6d136771541f3d2215e0ce31b1be45e99dbc64b43a4b734b447ca"],
+  ]
+}
 ```
 
 The event MUST have an `x` tag with the sha256 hash of the ordered concatenated hashes of each chunk
@@ -56,13 +62,27 @@ echo -e "\nRoot hash:"
 echo "$concatenated" | xxd -r -p | sha256sum
 ```
 
+The final `chunk` tags and `x` tag should look something like this
+
+```json
+{
+  "tags": [
+    [ "chunk", "7e668b56a58c7891e0cf263ea3f093b75eebade23d663a45aa9920f347b3d671"],
+    [ "chunk", "9b9c44a91396f19fd8700986eb0586dff2dcccf96c75bc2caefef302bcd78da1"],
+    [ "chunk", "7a281548f1223664b855b10b08e59e84389ccabeb742517f6cd75eda2724a798"],
+    [ "chunk", "fadeccee86b123088bbc452df10e8fbc99d4c2f22a70ef7a35605ec8e439c345"],
+    [ "chunk", "5d62398419e6d136771541f3d2215e0ce31b1be45e99dbc64b43a4b734b447ca"],
+    [ "x", "2d839865ac17d8bb10168490a88107637619f79dac21275fcec1705162581f39" ],
+  ]
+}
+```
+
 ### Metadata
 
 The `2001` event MAY include additional metadata tags to help other clients know the filename, mime type or servers to download from
 
 Metadata tags:
   - `name` Filename
-  - `summary` A short summary of the file
   - `mime` Mime type of file
   - `size` Total size in bytes of the file
   - `server` (multiple) Recommended servers to download chunks from
@@ -72,12 +92,17 @@ Metadata tags:
 Example `2001` event
 ```json
 {
-  "id": "13dfd656bedaca1f5fbb5da3b585d9c13061aa6aee136a0dc7d534f4d2540941",
-  "pubkey": "939e77d64e8eb5c240f60bf29f80a619d6057e70fcf5d25755da012fe1b9502e",
+  "id": "fd2f4da046851170576e7a09009e63f752dc469c61a24faca514b2cedfe641aa",
+  "pubkey": "5328e6c743a50271745e16476590ba7ea3dc591c65f3a5e2b03430814c1dabc0",
   "created_at": 1731405194,
   "kind": 2001,
-  "content": "7e668b56a58c7891e0cf263ea3f093b75eebade23d663a45aa9920f347b3d671\n9b9c44a91396f19fd8700986eb0586dff2dcccf96c75bc2caefef302bcd78da1\n7a281548f1223664b855b10b08e59e84389ccabeb742517f6cd75eda2724a798\nfadeccee86b123088bbc452df10e8fbc99d4c2f22a70ef7a35605ec8e439c345\n5d62398419e6d136771541f3d2215e0ce31b1be45e99dbc64b43a4b734b447ca",
+  "content": "Here is the original version",
   "tags": [
+    [ "chunk", "7e668b56a58c7891e0cf263ea3f093b75eebade23d663a45aa9920f347b3d671"],
+    [ "chunk", "9b9c44a91396f19fd8700986eb0586dff2dcccf96c75bc2caefef302bcd78da1"],
+    [ "chunk", "7a281548f1223664b855b10b08e59e84389ccabeb742517f6cd75eda2724a798"],
+    [ "chunk", "fadeccee86b123088bbc452df10e8fbc99d4c2f22a70ef7a35605ec8e439c345"],
+    [ "chunk", "5d62398419e6d136771541f3d2215e0ce31b1be45e99dbc64b43a4b734b447ca"],
     [ "x", "2d839865ac17d8bb10168490a88107637619f79dac21275fcec1705162581f39" ],
     [ "name", "example.mp4" ],
     [ "mime", "video/mp4" ],
@@ -85,6 +110,6 @@ Example `2001` event
     [ "server", "https://cdn.example.com" ],
     [ "server", "https://nostr.download" ]
   ],
-  "sig": "949b52a12fcd788eb416069b231e106eeb36b4987052c29904b547cabf5a52ebb42acfbce1ae61139042064b6950e69e322c5edbe77603ac2241a4d0e953ddd4"
+  "sig": "cd589a4ea702185c69d1fec93a7704265071b674c5708a1da04d08bcba873f5277bc0abb379cbb014852fafa2ac951ed49abbdba60028a4f02ef4e31ff2599cb"
 }
 ```